FattyWhale's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[She's The One]

Yeah

^^Good Points^^
The scenes in the movie went along with what was happening in the song pretty well.

^^Needs Improving^^
Well, the graphics weren't very good at all. The animations were too...solid. What I mean is that when people moved, very rarely did anything besides their whole being move, which looks pretty crappy. The music was a pretty dull, I thought it was going to be Smashing Pumpkins :(

As you said, this isn't a very good show of your talent.

Review Request Club.

JimmyDodger responds:

Thanks for the review first.

I tried to go with the song like you said I did. But I guess I went weak on the graphics. This was my first movie without using stick figures, so you cant really blame me. With the song, I just thought it would go with the style of the movie.

Thanks for the review.

[Brother Battle]

Good effort

^^Good Points^^
It seems as though you put some effort into this. The sprites were well animated and the movements looked somewhat realistic, good for what can be done with Mario sprites. The sound effects were right on queue and sounded great. I liked the different music used as well. This flash just feels good to watch because there isn't any obvious errors.

^^Needs Improving^^
This idea is really overdone, I see stuff like this all the time in the portal. It wasn't too exciting and nothing really out of the ordinary happened. Next time make something with a more original storyline.

Guitardude responds:

Originality on NG?

well that's just crazy talk.

but seriously don't worry about it. i'll try...

[Adolf N' Woodrow 01]

I don't like it

^^Good Points^^
This is a pretty funny idea...it never occured to me that these two could be compared in appearance and with a slight manipulation, look exactly the same. I always gotta laugh when I hear that song.

^^Needs Improving^^
This doesn't really seem like it should be considered a movie. The bulk and point of this submission was just a picture with some background music. Meaning, not a whole lot of effort or talent put into this submission.

AfroUnderscoreStud responds:

They look the same because they are the exact same person.

Lack of effort? Hey now, I spent a whole 10 seconds making this Flash!

[barbequebeefburger XVI]

Another...

^^Good Points^^
I like the graphical style in this. I like the staticy effect you added and how you made the corners look rounded, this is pretty cool. The sound was also nice, I can not get enough of that song. Plus the fact that you have Master Chief is pretty cool.

^^Needs Improving^^
This series is becoming just a waste. It's exactly the same except for whoever is crappily moved around the screen. Not even the backgrounds change. This is just like spam. It's annoying and useless.

Bbqbeefburgerman responds:

Spam?

OH NO

[The BBB Collab]

Not horrible

^^Good Points^^
The graphics, though they weren't too professional, suited the music and I thought were pretty well done. The song itself is an interesting song to make a collab for, but overall, this was a good collab.

^^Needs Improving^^
Each part of this collab repeats a lot, which gets pretty boring. You should try to make a collab that doesn't repeat so much.

N00bNation responds:

I agree.

[The Console Wars/Teaser]

Ok

^^Good Points^^
The graphics was this movie's best point. I liked the intro text and the clip of an Xbox 360 controller flying around in space, which is quite comical. The music is pretty crazy, and this is overall a pretty well done trailer.

^^Needs Improving^^
This idea has been done before, not sure if anything I've seen looks quite as good as this one, but it's not the most original idea.

TumbleWeedPro responds:

Heh heh, thanks for the review. Those were helpful tips. About the story though,I'm sure once you guys see the animation I'm sure you will think different. I'm doing my homework this time around and trust me Its going to be somthing you have never seen. Stay Tuned and thanks again. =3

[Feioras Story Part 2]

I'm impressed

^^Good Points^^
I'm very impressed by the graphics in this movie. The anime style of drawings and the amount of detail in this movie shows you have a lot of talent. The voice acting is very good as well, and was high quality stuff. The storyline is unique and seems very interesting, and I will definitely watch upcoming episodes. You obviously spend quite some time making this, and I'm impressed by the results.

^^Needs Improving^^
At some points the graphics just looked odd. Like the little boy's tail or whatever. It's just not consistent with the rest of the movie's graphics.

merit44 responds:

These are the comments that make my time and effort worth while. I plan to make the next one more 2d generated than 3d. I'm just burnt out from other animations I've had to complete recently -_-