FattyWhale's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Green Hills]

K

^^Good Points^^
The music was simply amazing. I should have known it was by Nobou before I looked at your credits. It was a very soothing and calming song, which I enjoyed listening to for a while.

^^Needs Improving^^
Yes...the hills are green, but I really don't need to see that for more than a couple of seconds before I get bored. You didn't really do much in this other than put some music to a background with pretty plain graphics and pretty plain animations. Both of these could use improving, with shading and stuff. And to reduce size you could have used some MC's instead of (what it seems like) putting everything and tweening everything on the timeline.

[Starship Blazdur III -ep2]

K

^^Good Points^^
A pretty funny movie. The voice overs were the best part of this, they were very intrestingly done and very unique. The drawings were good too, simplistic, yet good-looking. The storyline was very funny from beginning to end. A pretty enjoyable movie.

^^Needs Improving^^
I thought this started a little bit too slow. I was bored in the beginning of this until the movie actually started. Also, the graphics could definitely improve a bit, with some more shading.

[Control: A Research Paper]

K

^^Good Points^^
This was pretty interesting to read. You made up for a lot of the boring stuff by adding in some great drawings, like the city in the economy section, and still had some very interesting information in here. The graphics were set up very well, nice layout and very functional.

^^Needs Improving^^
Seeing that huge block of text really turned me off. You should split this into multiple frames just to get people to be more interested and less intimidated by such an amount of text.

[Slalom]

K

^^Good Points^^
A very good show of graphics. The shirt and hair of this guy blow in the wind, which shows you put some detail into your animations. The drawings were very good. I liked the character, and some of the further out scenes, like the views of the mountains, were expertly drawn. I like how you presented this in a cartoony way, and the music was very cool.

^^Needs Improving^^
No real storyline developed that was too interesting to me, so after the same stuff happening over and over, I got kind of bored with this. Some scenes, like when you get a view from this guy's eyes, things seem to be animated not as well as in other scenes (rocks/trees).

[Destroyer Clocks]

K

^^Good Points^^
Not bad drawings. You had tasteful use of gradients and the shaping was good with good drawings. I liked the speakonia, and once I understood the storyline, this was a pretty good movie.

^^Needs Improving^^
This movie was way too confusing the way you made it. I originally thought the black guy was killing the clocks, but for some reason you made it so that the stick figure with a clock face was the enemy of the clocks? That made no sense at all. It only started making sense once the last clock came out, and even now I'm not sure about this.

[Blob Wars]

K

^^Good Points^^
A pretty average random death match type movie. I liked the colors, they were pretty vibrant. The sound effects were well used and placed and appropriate. The graphics were decent, I liked the part where the grenade exploded in the air and shattered towards the screen, that was a cool effect.

^^Needs Improving^^
Some deaths were pretty lame, like when the guy just got a gun thrown at his head. Also, I can't say the deaths were really that creative. There wasn't anything in this movie that really stood out to me to make this better than anything else in the same genre.

[TwelveOhSix2006]

K

^^Good Points^^
A strange movie. The graphics were pretty good in the pre-movie. You had some good drawings in there, and the animations were pretty smooth. The music throughout this was all good choices.

^^Needs Improving^^
I didn't really find this too entertaining. It was just too random for me, and there wasn't any storyline developed in this. Then I was very disappointed at the actual movie, which was just a single frame.

numbers responds:

There IS a storyline here. Undeveloped? You don't need a 4 minute Flash to tell a simple plot :)

I wonder if you're just saying there's no plot because I didn't type it out like in ATTACK Of The Stereo..hm

thanks for the points, and critic to work on storylines (well that's a given but hgjdhf)

[spengbarb squirepents]

K

^^Good Points^^
That was freaky! And I enjoyed this because of it. It's one of my favorite animated shows, and you really scared me. These pictures were freaking weird looking, but they were all pretty funny to watch. The squidward ones had to be my favorite.

^^Needs Improving^^
The sound quality was pretty bad. I liked the song, but it had a lot of interference and sounded pretty bad. Same thing with some of the images, they just look like the quality was compromised for lower file size.