FattyWhale's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Red Speech]

K

^^Good Points^^
An interesting movie. You definitely get a lot of hate mail, and reading it all was pretty interesting. There were some really funny ones in this, and I'm glad you decided to showcase this. The background graphics were pretty well made, and I also like the different pictures you had in here. The sound set a cool mood too.

^^Needs Improving^^
These are always funnier when you actually read them and then make comments on them. Just reading them myself doesn't give the same effect as some submissions like "My favorite reviews". You should watch that to see what I mean.

[Sherlock Holmes: Xmas 06']

K

^^Good Points^^
This was quite good. I'm actually surprised that it didn't win at least a daily fifth place award considering its score and how well-made it was. The best part was the humor. It was a funny movie throughout. I liked Sherlock's open homosexuality throughout. The best scene had to be the first, with him finding the man in the chimney. The voice overs were very good. Clear and defined, and fit the characters.

^^Needs Improving^^
Some people just look a little oddly drawn. The ghosts mostly look quite strange in their shape and details, unlike say Sherlock and Watson.

Review Request Club

Pigmash responds:

Hey thanks, and I like this review requests thing, its made me want to review things more often too. Yeah, none of my Sherlock Holmes flashs win awards despite good scores and very favorable reviews, annoyingly if Id finished this 2 days earlier I could have gotten daily feature. So thanks for the feedback, and the new characters from the next episode Im currently spending a lot of time drawing.

[Bahamut: ATWI80D 03]

K

^^Good Points^^
We haven't seen much out of Bahamut in a while, so this was a surprise to see this here on NG. I'm pretty happy with the movie you made. The storyline was quite funny, especially towards the end. I would have never expected Afro_stud's hair to be a wig! I also like how much Hitler was included in this movie, which added a lot of humor. The music was good as always, with something from Final Fantasy, Mindless self indulgence, and also T Spoon. A great soundtrack!

^^Needs Improving^^
It's unfortunate that you are going to discontinue this series, since I really enjoyed it, but whatever. You already know everything I'm going to say down here anyway, so I won't bother :P

kinggila responds:

I had to discontinue this series since continuing this any longer would be quite pointless since Adolf Hitler: ATWI80D is completed. And yes, anything that looks bad here, I gotta try and improve it for next time, lol.

[LOL TANKMEN]

K

^^Good Points^^
I haven't seen a Tankmen parody in a long time, so this is neat. It was a pretty average parody, and it had some good parts. The CG voices were good even though most used real voice overs. The graphics were pretty decent too, some cool drawings. The script was pretty funny too, I got some laughs.

^^Needs Improving^^
A little late for the Tankmen fad to have a real effect on your score. You should have submitted it a long time ago when the fad was still going on.

DrunkAlien responds:

Yeah, I know. :P

Thanks. :)

[Metal Gear: Untitled]

K

^^Good Points^^
The graphics were decent. Pretty good shading, and pretty good animations too. The animations had to be the best though, very smooth.

^^Needs Improving^^
This was more an annoyance than anything. That scene with the stereo or whatever was just incredibly annoying with that stupid beeping noise going off for way too long. The storyline wasn't very funny, and didn't make a whole lot of sense. I had absolutely no idea what the ending was about.

EB3 responds:

aggg for the love of god ITS A DAMN METAL DETECTOR!!! THAT GOES BEEP BEEP BEEP SO SNAKE TRIES TO GET RID OF HIS ITEMS!! BLEH. and there was no ending

[Trek Lovin]

K

^^Good Points^^
This movie was kind of entertaining. I thought the gargoyle with giant penis statue, and the sound clips went well together and created a very odd storyline. Good quality sound and what not.

^^Needs Improving^^
I didn't like the bitmap of the Enterprise, it just looks out of place. The animations were pretty crude too. You could have animated some more on the smaller scale, like arms and legs rather than just entire bodies.

[Castle Commercial]

K

^^Good Points^^
Hah! I played the game Defend Your Castle before, but it never even crossed my mind that this would be an add for the game, but a wonderful one at that. The graphics were great, first off, better than most movies on NG. I loved how you started this out, I really had no idea what this was going to be about, and it was such a surprise to see what happened at the end, which was made very well, and very surprising. Great job on this!

^^Needs Improving^^
Really nothing that I can think of. This was a very delightful movie.

[AOL shark]

K

^^Good Points^^
A very odd storyline in this, but still very creative and very funny. I got that the guy wants to kill Jenny because she has inside jokes in her profile? That was kind of strange, but very funny. I liked the character you created, his voice overs were very good. The ending was hilarious too, I really laughed at this, "I will accept this citizenship award". Classic!

^^Needs Improving^^
The graphics could use some improving. The guy's face wasn't very detailed, he didn't have eye details, and the animations were even worse. Also, the voice overs got hard to hear towards the middle of this.

[Fadgrounds]

K

^^Good Points^^
A neat movie depicting the many odd fads on NG that have surfaced. I like how you had screenshots from each fad, and the music was very effective for the mood. I liked your drawings of the Flash and the backgrounds.

^^Needs Improving^^
I think you could have added in some more fads into this, for more of a history of them, like BBQ and stuff like that.

Hoogiman responds:

K.

[Ultimate Prophet Movie]

K

^^Good Points^^
Half decent graphics. You had some good drawings in this, with good coloring, and mixed sprites with your own drawings.

^^Needs Improving^^
I really didn't get this. The movie made no sense, and it had no storyline at all that I could detect. You had a bunch of random events that seemed unrelated, and no music or sound effects to even spruce that up. Then when I got the the "Enter your spell" part, the button didn't seem to work.