FattyWhale's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Showreel 2007]

(title in work)

^^Good Points^^
It was a very solid collection. You're work is obviously pretty professional, and all of this looks very well made. I really liked the music that went along with it.

^^Needs Improving^^
As you said, video quality was odd. How were these movies made?

RubberNinja responds:

These movies were all made in flash, it's just generally my stuff has been made for TV.. So they're all in video format. Sticking a showreel like this together in Flash is painful.. SO I tend not to. Plus I lost some of the FLA files to some of this work.

[Madness Consternation]

(title in work)

^^Good Points^^
A great addition to your resume. It was very strange in the beginning with the fiery thing and all the major enemies. Definitely great graphics and music as always. Nothing short of what I expected.

^^Needs Improving^^
I still find it a bit lame that the guy just gets through so many enemies based solely on the fact that they are terrible fighters.

[Marsh-Mellow-Madness]

(title in work)

^^Good Points^^
I liked the music, and this also had its share of humor. The ending was quite unexpected, though why did I expect someone to live in a Madness short?

^^Needs Improving^^
Just not really my style of madness. It's a bit boring and the ending wasn't very satisfying. Just didn't really have fun watching it.

[Madness Apotheosis]

(title in work)

I've never actually watched an official Madness movie, as I thought all the fan-made episodes were complete crap. This wasn't too bad though. There was excellent animation and art throughout, with very realistic blood. Lots of chaos and carnage...to each his own. It wasn't quite as good as I thought it would be, with all the hype about it, but still nonetheless a true classic.

[Luigi Nr.1]

(title in work)

This could use a whole lot of improvement. The first thing that I noticed, and the reason that I voted to delete this, was the size of the sprites. You put tiny characters against huge backgrounds, which just makes it look like it was done by a child. This got pretty darn boring after a while, seeing how Luigi just pulls out a gun on every single character and kills them. You need to get a little bit more creative with this.

[Making the Band part 1]

(title in work)

Meh, it really wasn't that impressive. The graphics were pretty cheap. Triangle characters didn't look that good. The jokes weren't very funny, which didn't help this out. I felt like I had to wait a while to get a laugh out of this, and even then it really wasn't that funny. Needs more jokes squeezed in between the main ones. Good luck.

[eggs and you]

(title in work)

^^Good Points^^
Interesting, nonetheless. I liked the improvised lyrics, they were quite funny...eggs talking about doom...

^^Needs Improving^^
I thought this was going to be more of PSA type thing with the way the title was..."eggs and you". However, I was disappointed when I just saw it was some eggs lip synced to some music.

[HP: the Alternate Ending]

(title in work)

^^Good Points^^
I've never read Harry Potter, but I still think this wasn't too bad. Graphics were simple, but still looked detailed. Interesting twists in this as well.

^^Needs Improving^^
A bit short. I think you could have done a bit more to accommodate people who know nothing about HP, like me.