FattyWhale's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[runaL]

Ok

It is neat how you took an audio track and reversed it. I sure would not have known if you hadn't said that. Anyway, the song itself isn't too interesting. It sounds like the same notes played over and over with little variation throughout the song. And then it ended really abruptly, which I don't like.

Review Request Club

[Pink Floyd - Money (cover)]

Ok

This was a pretty good cover. The guitar solo was a little rough, but it has personality. I don't know much about guitar playing, but you sound pretty well trained to me. I just have one question: Did you take the guitar out of the original and put your own in and leave everything else? or is this completely original?

Review Request Club.

FrozenSheep responds:

its actually a backtrack i downloaded from guitarbt.com A backtrack is a song but without the lyrics and the lead guitar.

[Fuzzy Bean]

Ok

I really liked how unique of a song this was. It is in the jazz category, yet it has a very strange feel to it that doesn't remind me of jazz at all. You used a lot of different instruments than in most jazz songs, which I think did it. Cool song.

[Death to the pharoah]

Ok

One thing I really like about this song is the title. It's quite original, and goes good with a heavy metal song. I like how you started with this "slow acoustic tempo" that I'm not familiar with, and how the song builds up to the end. However, it is very clear that in some parts the guitar work, which was good, had a few mistakes. You should try adding some percussion to this next time.

blackmantis1 responds:

yeah it does have alot of mistakes man. But this was at 8 in the morning so w/e. thanks for the review man. Ill try to work on getting drums. Im looking into beatcraft. Thanks.

[Hollingsworth- Hard]

ok

Heh, this really reminds me of the music from the DOOM series of video games. It's probably the same basic sounds. Anyway, this didn't sound very "rockish" to me. It sounded more techno. The beat was pretty good, but I think you made the percussion in this a little too strong.

[Blue Future]

Ok

I'm usually not liking DnB music, but this one didn't seem too bad. I liked how you made it sound like it was moving from speaker to speaker. not sure if you were going for this, but it certainly worked, nonetheless. I liked the wind sounding stuff and how you changed the intensity of the song throughout.

Hollingsworth responds:

Hey, thanks! I actually did want to make the sound go from speaker to speaker. Thanks again for the review

[Star Stealing Girl CC]

Ok

I've never heard the original song, so I'm not sure what to compare this to, but it was still a pretty good song. This started kind of slowly, but it still had a lot of good diversity in it towards the end and overall this was a good song.

[Phantasy Star 2 Battle]

Ok

A classic tune from a classic game, no doubt it has to be great. You maintained the original song, yet still added your own flare to it, which is nice. This is a very intense tune and is very lively. I like it quite a bit, nice job.

Realmguys responds:

Hey thanks a lot! I loved this game so much, you will be seeing more phantasy star from me.

[Blue Sunshine]

OK

Ok, I'm no music guru, and I don't know much about making music, but this was really kind of boring to me. It just played the same tune over and over, I really think you should add some more diversity into this to make it more interesting.

[March of the Tankmen (0:43)]

Ok

I wasn't really a fan of the movie, and didn't watch the whole thing, mainly because it bored me to death, so I'm not sure how much influence it has on this submission or whether you just stuck tankmen in the title. Either way, it's a pretty good song. It's got a lot of diversity in such a short length and has a nice tempo.

WinTang responds:

It's for an audio contest based on that flash, find the thread "MAC6 - August" in the Audio Forum if you're interested - so the influence is pretty big :)
Thanks for the review!