FattyWhale's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Sword of Lamneth City Theme]

(title in work)

Actually sounds very good. Definitely sounds like it could go well with a video game, though I'm not sure exactly which game this is supposed to go for. The only problem I found was that it doesn't loop very well at all. Very disjointed when replaying. Definitely need a calmer end to this to go with the calm introduction.

suppi responds:

the problem with looping is the player, not the song. but i see what you mean by it.

[Contra-Level1-Jungle-Remix]

(title in work)

I've never seen any audio from Contra, which is one of my favorite games ever made. This was a very solid remix and sounded good throughout. My only complaint is that it doesn't really loop all that well as I listen to it.

[F-Zero - Bigger Blue]

(title in work)

It is definitely a quality piece and very well made. However, nothing really stuck out in it that made me really like it or think it was really that great. Very repetitive mostly.

[LoZ: Minish Cap - Village]

(title in work)

Well, I've never heard the original, but this was pretty good. You made this sound very neat and it had a lot of different sections and tunes to it throughout. Sounds like it came right out of a video game.

[Ice Cold Dreams - Sonic 3]

(title in work)

Not too bad of a remix. You are good at remixing, it seems. Some great percussion added into this and a fresh new feeling to the song. I'm not sure if this is just my computer or not, but the quality seemed really low. I didn't take off for that though.

[DDR So Deep (Arcane Remix)]

(title in work)

An excellent piece of audio you made. I know the original song quite well, and I like how you gave it a completely different feel and sound to it, but kept it still very close to the original. However, I think you could have done a little bit more original, as it is pretty much the original song just with a different tune. Could have added an original part to this or something.

[==(Frost)==]

(title in work)

Very interesting for an ambient work. Unlike most ambient pieces, this one was actually pretty interesting, as it contained some guitar and some percussion as well, which gave it a well rounded feeling. Really liked this one, great job on it.

[--[[Move]]--]

(title in work)

Neat song you have here. It has a really unique beat and feel to it. I liked the mix of many different instruments throughout to make it more interesting. Best was the brass though. Very professionally made, great job.

UberKuri responds:

Ty, makes me smile to hear that lol.

[Why - Live/Accoustic/Unplugged]

Not bad

I realize this was a live show, so the audio can't be that great of quality. The guitar work was really good, definitely some skill there. The vocals however, I didn't really like. Sounded a little strained to me and a bit unnatural. I don't know what work you've done, but maybe you should try some other tone or something.

Naitzmic responds:

Thanks for the review.
I agree with just about everything you said,
so this won't be much of a response...

Your input is much appreciated though.