FattyWhale's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Pineapple Song]

OK

This was a cool track because of the calmness of the whole thing. You played very smoothly throughout the song, but I really didn't like how there wasn't much diversity to it. You didn't change much up, sounded like the same stuff, over and over.

[suzuki techno]

Ok

The thing I liked about this was the happy feeling tune of it. A very cool sound you had here. You had some diversity throughout this, and the handclap set up a powerful beat. Next time, try to incorporate some more sounds into this instead of using the same ones a lot. Change the song around and have a slow part, or speed it up.

DnX-Danefex responds:

thx for the review and thanks for the criticizm, i make my song useing the demo.lol. and yeah ill incorporate some of oyur comments into my next song.

[SM64 Darkness +1]

Ok

A good video game remix you have here. The tones you used were very cool, and I like how you even incorporated some sounds into this that were from the actual game. This had quite a bit of diversity, with lots of different stuff throughout. A good effort by you.

CyrusOfNaias responds:

Thank you sir. Need all the help I can get!

[Delay Lama- Sunrise [fixed]]

Ok

This was a decent song. It definitely was made up of some unique sounds, and I really like how all of your titles paint a picture in one's mind when they listen. I thought this song was a little bit lacking, since you only used a few different sounds to make up this entire song.

EchozAurora responds:

Thanks.. yeah, these were pretty minimal.

[Aquaduct]

Ok

This was a pretty interesting song you had. I liked the bubbling sound in the background, which went with the Aquaduct title you have here. The mood set by this song was pretty cool. It was calm, but had a sort of speedy beat to it.

[StarSailing (Demo)]

Ok

This was a little disappointing to me. It was rather boring to be quite honest. You basically just used the same sounds over and over to create a beat. It could be a decent song if you expanded a little more on this with some more going on in terms of other sounds, but as it is now, a little lame.

[Ancient Technology]

Ok

Another good song made by you. The description was very interesting in this song, I was intrigued to listen to it. It did not really disappoint me much. There was a lot of diverse sounds, yet still a lot of repeating of the same sounds. It also sounded very simple, which went along with the description.

[Echoz- Assault]

Ok

This was really a cool song. At first it sounded pretty run-of-the-mill, but towards the middle you started adding that scream sound clip and started playing that almost like an instrument, and same with the trumpet, which really made this an interesting song. I liked it!

Review Request Club

[Zelda: Windmill]

Ok

This song was a very good one by you. I'm not familiar with the original version of this song, but nonetheless, this song is awesome. You had quite a few different instruments going on in here, and it had a very calming feel to it that I really liked. Definitely a fun tune to listen to.

Soundshifter responds:

thank you for the nice review, and for your ears. :)

[ParagonX9 - No. 5 (NG Edit)]

Ok

This was a very cool song you made here. It was very diverse, with constantly changing beats and lots of different instrumental noises in it as well. It seemed to change BPM a lot throughout and also it had ups and downs with the tone and varied a lot.