FattyWhale's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[A World's Rigors]

(title in work)

Another good musical piece by you. It definitely had that epic sound to it. Something like would be in a movie as a hero is riding to battle or something like that. Not sure exactly what it has to do with the games you listed in the description though. Care to explain that?

[-=Garage Rock=-]

(title in work)

Simplicity has definitely worked for you hear. You have a basic drum loop in the background and some simple guitar sounds to go along with it. Nothing too fancy, but it really sounds pretty good when put together. A few different parts throughout make this enjoyable to listen to the whole thing.

Mataro responds:

Hey.. I put a lot of time into those drums.. xD

Simplicity was the idea, though. Happy to hear it worked out. I'm fairly proud of this one.. It's really a fun song :P

Thanks for the review! :D

[TheReno-[Hard fought Victory]]

(title in work)

Once again, not really a fan of a piece by you. I think the main reason is that there isn't enough going on in this song. It's mostly just one or two different instruments playing at one time, which doesn't lead to a very interesting song. You could have at least added some percussion or something to this to make it more interesting.

TheReno responds:

[See response under little-rena review]

[TheReno-[Sonata of the Stars]]

(title in work)

I just listened to the other audio you requested a review for, and I don't really think I like your style. There just doesn't seem to be a very dominant sound to your audios. They seem to be focusing on one instrument and sound, which makes them kind of boring to me.

TheReno responds:

I chose to respond to this one because its the one that mentions my other songs. I try not to play a dominant sound too much because I feel it takes away from the overall effect. Instead I play a base beat, one that appears throughout the song. Keeps the beat that way and I never forget where I am in a song.

[Rebellion of the Patriots -T.R]

(title in work)

Not too bad. It did have a pretty classical feeling though, with the organs going on throughout this. Not sure I really liked it though. Seemed a little disjointed and made on a whim and didn't make much sense to me. Melodies were a little weird. Overall, not something that I would save, but not bad.

[==(Frozen Planet)==]

(title in work)

I guess a new ice age is an interesting way to describe this song. I definitely feel that with this song though. It was really calm, and almost-alien like. I thought maybe it was a bit long though, especially since it seemed a bit repetitive too. Still good to just chill to though.

[The monks]

(title in work)

Haven't seen the movie, so I'm not quite sure what these monks are. However, it was kind of a cool way to start out a metal song. Sounds like some kind of ritual going on or something. The transition didn't seem too smooth between the parts though, and that is what bothered me the most.

Bonemill responds:

Lol, they walk aorund hitting themselves in the head with bibles chanting this.

[E1M1 - Hangar]

(title in work)

Another great Doom song remixed with a metal twist to it. Really liked the guitar work, in here, it really fit well and gave this a very quick pace to it. So far the best remix of Hangar that I've ever heard. Interesting beginning to it as well, sounds like something reversed?

[Entryway]

(title in work)

Not your best remix, though still great. I'm listening to the guitar solo of this right now, and it really makes the song. I was about to rate it lower because I didn't think it was metal enough, but hearing the solo makes me give it an 8 instead of a 7. Another great sounding Doom remix here.

[E1M9 - Military Base]

(title in work)

This was an awesome Doom remix you have, of a very well-known song from Doom. I never thought of it as a heavy metal song, but this was pretty awesome. I especially like towards the end, when the percussion starts to become more erratic. It really makes the song unique. Great job.