FattyWhale's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[[CC] - Change]

(title in work)

Heh, so I'm assuming that you got banned from the CC boards for this? I've heard the mods there are pretty bitchy sometimes. It was a funny movie, with a good ending to it. You really stuck it to those meanie mods! Nice use of speakonia, and the simple graphics did their job.

Madanimation responds:

Thanks for the awesome review! :D

[Cats & Dogs]

(title in work)

Not a great movie. I've heard the exact joke done in cartoons before, so it's nothing new. Graphically it wasn't terrible. The rain animation was pretty good, but there wasn't much else besides that. You need to distinguish who is talking during your movies, and also, make your voice a bit clearer, I couldn't tell what the hell you were saying half the time.

MetalAnt responds:

Thnanks Alot

[-CONFLICT-]

(title in work)

That's it? I was expecting something more out of this. I sat watching that whole movie, expecting some good joke at the end, but it was just the most predictable thing ever. Really uninteresting storyline, not helped by the lack luster voice acting. Just nothing special overall.

INDRE responds:

Well you`re wrong. It it special :P It was one of the first flash cartoons i`ve made. And I was very young at that time so...

Overall, I know, it`s a bad one. Still, it took hell of a time.

[Gnu 3]

(title in work)

Well, at least he didn't take a shit this time, so this episode wasn't quite as predictable as the previous ones. Overall I didn't find it that entertaining. Just a weird storyline and another weird adventure with Gnu. Also, this episode was much shorter than the rest, which was a bit disappointing.

golfinho responds:

Yes! I didnt like to make GNU episodies, but i make for yhe site cartoonshoow. Now i make GNU 4 for me.

[Gnu 1]

(title in work)

Well, certainly better than the first. The audio problems you had with the first seem to be much improved now. The graphics are nice looking. Good animations and drawings as well. The whole theme of him pooping all over everything was a bit repetitive and not that funny I would say. This was funnier than the first though, so the series is at least improving thus far.

golfinho responds:

GNU not is a Good Serie! GNU is a unknown not bad Serie! >: O

[The Creep]

(title in work)

Hmm, a nice, short collab overall. I'm not really sure how you went about constructing this, but the graphical styles throughout did not change much at all, which is one of the things I like about collaborations. Regardless, it was well drawn and animated. The music was quite good, and went well with this. The ending was a bit of a disappointment, but unexpected nonetheless. Overall, a pretty good movie.

[[TT] CD09 -thdrky-]

(title in work)

Really this seemed like more of a barrage of black stereotypes and jokes rather than an insult to thedrkness. That really took away from the purpose of this movie for me. Overall very boring, since there was no animation at all, and the art wasn't good to begin with. Definitely could have used some more animations and scene changes.

Review Request Club.

YukariYakumo responds:

Yeah, I know. Since we started at 5PM Clock Day we really didn't have time to make anything better, but next time I'll make sure we start earlier.

[F L i G H T]

(title in work)

I just can't knock anything that someone puts so much time and effort into. Your passion for this project was clear and everything was well thought out. Throughout this movie we see many abstract things that really tickle the mind and make you think about what is going on not only in the movie but in our lives as well.

Review Request Club.

someplaceelse responds:

Thank you so much. Your review really helped me. I'm glad you thought about my cartoon this way ^_^

[Mac, PC, and a Hedgehog]

(title in work)

This had it's high points and low points. I enjoyed how you made Mac a cracked out dude, since I'm not a fan of Mac's. I don't really get this entirely though. Why would thing that does the tasks of MobianWare compete against computers? In any event, the graphics were a mixed bag. The lip syncing was pretty good, but the animations overall were pretty simple and not extremely well done. An interesting story, but I think it went on for a bit too long, especially with the looping 30 second jingle in the background.

Review Request Club.

RecD responds:

yeah, I'm going to try to keep future animations fresher.

[Tim Burton's "A Pirate"]

(title in work)

Lol, I think the best part about this is the commentary and the interviews. Quite well done there. The movie itself was interesting. A neat drawing style and cool music as well. I thought it was funny how you put words instead of drawings stuff. A good storyline as well. Lots of good pirate dialogue.

ClockRadio responds:

Tim Burton is now sick and tired of the fanboys to this film. He wants nothing to do with anyone.