FattyWhale's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Goodbye, BroccoliClock]

(title in work)

Not that bad. Sadly I am not familiar with the story of BroccoliClock, so this story is strange to me. However, I enjoyed the scenery you used for the background and the storyline was interesting. A bit short, and the artwork wasn't that great, but still a funny movie overall.

[Animation Kills]

(title in work)

Well done overall. You were very careful with the sound effects. They were very clear and... I guess detailed. Or at least very well placed and comprehensive. The animation looked a little strange at times. Almost like the guy was a puppet or something. Not sure if that's what you were going for, but it looked a little odd to me. I thought the ending was good though. The sudden mix of color emphasized the violence, and the guy randomly shooting himself was quite unexpected. Nice job.

Soupcat responds:

Yeh it gets kinda dodgy sometimes with the joints and everything.

But people mostly complained about the sounds tho xD

So this is new. But thanks for the nice review and all that jazz ^^

["EXTINCT"]

(title in work)

This movie was very well done in just about every aspect, and seeing how this is only your 5th solo movie, that is quite impressive. Your choices of music were very good and appropriate for the scenes. The storyline was also quite good and had a message that is relateable for the audience. Seems like the graphics were slightly fuzzy at some parts though, I guess due to filesize limits.

Overall a great movie, good luck in the future!

manuelberja responds:

thanks!
:)

[Rape is Bat]

(title in work)

Wow, that was really fucking strange to say the least. I can't say it was really enjoyable though. The drawings were quite good. Animation was kind of minimal though. Overall, some shock humor, but that is about it, and it really didn't appeal to me too much.

[That a Man Will Also Reap]

Heh, so fantastic

Very well put together. The intro set the mood and setting quite well, and it was humorous as well. I have to say the movie wasn't that interesting until the ending when the massacre happened. That was quite unexpected and hilarious. Kudos, keep it up!

[The Shape N' Shape Collab]

(title in work)

I've never actually watched any of the original Shape N' Shape submissions, so this is all new to me. I have to say that it wasn't much more than I expected it to be. The content was really hit or miss. Sometimes it was rather funny, but sometimes not. And since this series really depends completely on dialogue, since there is no animation or artwork, you're kind of putting all of your eggs in one basket.

Though not a great collab by any means, it is a part of NG history I suppose, so I commend you for putting all of this together.

Review Request Club.

ChandlerThompson responds:

Thanks for the review, Mr. Milinko.

The content is purely judgmental, I can't disagree with that. We tried to imitate and mock the shape fad at the same time throughout this collab, so I suppose you received two different takes on what the shape popularity was about.

Dialogue was an important feature in the flash, so I appreciate you talking about it and helping all the users who participated in the collab improve. Thanks again for the swell review!

[One Little Fix]

(title in work)

Yeah, a pretty good V-day movie. It some good dialogue I think. I want to say there were some good metaphors, but then everything seemed quite literal in this, which made this movie unique in its own way. The animation was good, though I think at times the drawings were a bit too sketchy.

[2,000,000 Pageviews]

(title in work)

First off, congrats on the milestone! I think this was a good tribute to your hard work. Original songs are always awesome, and you did a great job writing this one. I quite enjoyed the lyrics, they were funny and relevant. Well animated too. The only thing I didn't like was the first 30 seconds before the song started...it wasn't an intro that really made me want to keep watching this. Glad I did though!

[A Reunion]

(title in work)

Well done! It's kind of neat to be able to do something artistic for you girl, I'm sure she will like it. It was well animated, and nice attention to detail in the animations, like moving the hair just slightly when his head moves. Music went along with this well, and overall presented nicely. Good one!

[Doppelganger Week]

(title in work)

Haha, excellent job on this. The voice acting you used made this quite funny. The animations that went with it were quite fast, which I think went well with this. Very funny jokes and timing. Nicely done!

Hoogiman responds:

thanks!