FattyWhale's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Consult]

Strange but ok.

^^Good Points^^
I think the graphics were the best part of this movie. I liked how you made the beginning look like it was on a computer. The animations and blood actually looked pretty good. The storyline was a little weird but I liked it overall. I also thought there were some ironic and funny things to it, like how the man was killed by a wierd plunger gun.

^^Needs Improving^^
The wierdness to it has its drawbacks as well. I didn't really understand why this guy started killing people with his mouse. Explain if you could.

The-Joker-xD responds:

(i don't know english too good, but i will try to answer)
the movie is a little weird you know, and the why of a person killing with a mouse was by a error in the swf... (that is weird you know xD) Like everything that part is weird and is part of the madness... THX for the review

[Thinkcomix Dead n Alive2]

Nah...

^^Good Points^^
As always, nice drawings and nice interactive frame by frame type comic you've got here.

^^Needs Improving^^
This whole series has been devoid of sound, which really bothers me. Also the joke in this one wasn't really funny at all. It is a little unbelievable that the dog would mistake an earing for a frisbee type thing, and he killed her for it? I'm not liking this. And again, no interactivity like the first two.

[Thinkcomix Dead n Alive1]

Err...ok...

^^Good Points^^
The drawings were nice as this always is, and the interface is well made and is appealing visually as well.

^^Needs Improving^^
I was dismayed to find that this one didn't have an interactive section, which is really why I like the other ones, and this also didn't have much animation at all. It felt a lot like a regular still frame comic. The storyline was also a little weird. A girl gets dirt thrown on her, then the old lady's plants fall on her? what?

Thinkcomix responds:

Firstly, all your comments are appreciated (good or bad).
We try to make the comics "short and sharp" type but however it seems a little bit too short and too simple like most of you mentioned.
Will make improvements!

[Jake Kenny 1990 - 2006]

Inside jokes?

^^Good Points^^
The music was the only good part of this movie, it fit the mood pretty well and was noticable, but still relatively subtle.

^^Needs Improving^^
I don't know if this is some joke I haven't come across yet or if this is inside humor, but at this point I don't think this is funny at all. The graphics were also pretty horrible, mainly the animations. Not sure who Jake Kenny is either.

[Wheres my schnitzel]

So-so

^^Good Points^^
Not sure where you got the sound from, but I liked it. It was a tad bit humorous, but was pretty random (and not the funny kind of random).

^^Needs Improving^^
The animations are very sloppy, they look like South Park, which in Flash movies means you are bad at animation. The part where the guy went to the kitchen was lame too... He kind of just sat on the side for a minute.

[Freerun: Go-Man, Scene 1]

No doubt, some of the best graphics ever

^^Good Points^^
As the title suggests, I am very highly impressed with the graphics in this movie. You superbly blended real life images with superb anime style drawings. The camera angles and constant perspective angles changing is freaking awesome. This really reminds me of the scenes from the Spiderman movies with him flying through the city. I loved the intro, and this storyline seems like it will deliver a good service to NG.

^^Needs Improving^^
Making a second part as good as this one will be hard.

[Ammugammu]

Wut?

^^Good Points^^
I liked the beginning part with those wierd looking creatures. That was pretty cool and I expected a lot more to come out of this.

^^Needs Improving^^
After the scene with those wierd drum-playing snail things, this went downhill. The whole trip scene was nothing but some shape tweens, which was really boring and after that, you just lost me. I was expecting this to be a music video from the beginning, which would have been a nice show, but alas...

[Happy Days wheyyyyy]

Random...yeah

^^Good Points^^
Well, the best part about this is the graphics (though they aren't even too impressive). The beginning showed some good animation in it.

^^Needs Improving^^
I'm kind of torn between whether random is a good thing or not. I guess it really depends on my mood and exactly what happens. Unfortunately, this type of random is not my cup o' tea. It wasn't really funny at all, and was just a waste of my time to watch.

[Final Fantasy 7 Battle]

I lol'd

^^Good Points^^
I usually don't actually laugh out loud when I say I do, but for this I actually somewhat did. Actually, it was more of a wierd grunting type thing, but hey, that's more than most movies get. This was pretty funny. The graphics were pretty good, I liked how you drew the l33t translator dude, and the noob cannon was hella funny. Did I mention that this is funny?

^^Needs Improving^^
The beginning is a little bit wierd, I didn't really get the purpose. The close up graphics of Cloud's face etc, could use some touching up as well.