FattyWhale's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[TF2 - Rocketman]

(title in work)

I think the idea of a TF2 sprite movie is a good idea. The idea of a game is even better though, which is what I thought this was part way through. I enjoyed your usage of sound effects in this, that really helped this out. The animations weren't too interesting though. Everything moved a bit too slow for my tastes.

[Boogie Boogie Hedgehog]

(title in work)

This is quite possibly the best thing I have ever seen. The music was amusing, and somehow this didn't lose its novelty even towards the end. I really enjoyed how you drew and animated this, especially the Hedgehog's face, which looked sort of stupid/demented. Great work! Make a longer and better version!

[LSD Dance]

(title in work)

It wasn't so much trippy as it was just weird. The loop doesn't offer much...simply a guy jumping up and down with some flashing colors. I wasn't too impressed by this really. Felt just a bit too happy and crazy to me.

[Stress Bunny]

(title in work)

This was a pretty awesome FBF animation. You were really creative with this. I especially like the part where the octopus things keep reproducing from their mouths. That was quite unique. This flowed very well with the music. Very nice.

[A Boy and his Truck]

(title in work)

Looks like the animation class paid off, as that is one thing you really nailed in this was the animation. I especially liked the scene where he is running towards the fence. It was very well done. The storyline was nothing special though. I was expecting you to take it a bit further and perhaps have the boy cause some other havoc around town.

Commanderloochy responds:

I'm planning on adding to this, but this was all I was able to make in the week we had for the final project. I'll probly continue working on this, and upload it when it's maybe a couple minutes long.

[Saturday Morning Watchmen]

(title in work)

The satire of this movie was excellent! Both of the Watchmen series and Saturday cartoons. You really did a good job of emulating the latter, with the cheesy lyrics and deep singing voice. Expertly animated and drawn, everything looks great in this one. Very nice job, I like this one a lot.

[Cats and Dogs]

(title in work)

I think you accurately personified both cats and dogs in here. The cat, more sophisticated, and the dog more laid back. Graphically this was pretty good. Even though it is eight years old the graphics are still impressive. Lip syncing seemed a bit off at times though. A funny story, quite enjoyable.

[Finding Nemo commercial]

(title in work)

I kind of remember these commercials being a bit more subtle. You rapidly went through a bunch of pictures and then hit the punchline. You really could have used some better quality images for sure. The joke wasn't bad though, I enjoyed that.

[dancing leaf]

(title in work)

A decent first flash. The music went well with the simplicity of this, and honestly I felt it fit the color of the background if that makes sense. As far as comparing this to other similar movies, this was nothing special. You need to have more going on simultaneously rather than just one thing. Also, try to smooth out your drawings with the paintbrush a bit.