FattyWhale's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[Game Snake]

k

I hate nothing more on all of NG more than these crappy snake games that come through the portal every day. All you did was follow a tutorial, if not just copy an open source snake game and just edit a few symbols and add in your own music. Nothing in this is original or sets this apart from other snake games. Please make your own game next time instead of just copying a really crappy one.

[SBC killz teh evil clocks]

K

^^Good Points^^
Ok, interesting idea for a game. I like how you drew your own characters as well, instead of using crappy pictures off the web.

^^Needs Improving^^
This game really isn't that fun. The graphics aren't good, which doesn't really help at all, and there is no sound effects or music. The game itself is really basic and there isn't much to it. You could atleast have a score or different waves, etc.

[Noodle Salad]

K

^^Good Points^^
I originally saw this on Clock Day and was pleasantly surprised to see that you, SBC got in on the action of clock day and submitted a movie. Parts of this were kind of funny, in fact pretty much all of it was funny and the randomness just made me laugh.

^^Needs Improving^^
Watching this again after my mind has settled back into a normal state since clock day, this really is no different than your other work. Lack luster graphics and events that have nothing to do with each other.

[Stewie Griffin SB]

K

^^Good Points^^
Ok, quite a few sounds in this one. They were all pretty good quality and were good for a soundboard, since they all contain just stewie talking.

^^Needs Improving^^
For one, there are who knows how many stewie soundboards on NG and the internet, and this one compared to them is not very impressive. The graphics are really quite lack luster, and this isn't particularly good for making prank calls since everything is scattered about.

[Blockhead Soundboard]

K

^^Good Points^^
I was always wanting to make one of these for BH, but never really got around to it. How did you go about getting the sounds? I was going to record every episode then isolate them...probably why I never did it. :D Anyway, very good soundboard. Jam packed with three pages of funny clips from BH himself, one of my favorite characters. Lots of humor and great for prank calling.

^^Needs Improving^^
I don't really like the intro since it doesn't look at all like Swain's intro, and the buttons were kind of ugly, as were the background images.

wizardman responds:

That's basically what I did, I went through every episode and just ripped them with Sound Recorder. I was tryign to make the intro not look exactly like Swain's to avoid plagiarism. It's his intro :P. Yeah, the bg images weren't great, but I didn't have any other ideas.

[DDR: K]

K

^^Good Points^^
Drawings were half decent, pretty detailed. The music choices were also pretty good, though music from DDR would have been better

^^Needs Improving^^
This game is pretty stupid. The animations aren't really that good, especially since the dude's arms are in four different pieces. The moves are pretty stupid and this isn't entertaining at all. The worst part is that there is no preloader, so I'm sitting here just itching to hit those buttons while your uncompressed music is loading.

[Clock Pong]

K

^^Good Points^^
The best part about this was the graphics. I like how you incorporated a bunch of different clocks into this and the background is well done.

^^Needs Improving^^
The game is very glitchy. If orange hits the center, he bounces around in there for a second, and I don't really see any other clocks trying to kill me as was explained in the instructions. Interesting graphics, but not a very fun game.

Lone-Ronin1 responds:

Well it is my first game. So of course there are glitches. but Iam glad you liked the graphics.

[Ultimate Homer Soundboard]

K

^^Good Points^^
Lots of sound clips in this. All of the buttons seemed to work and the clips were nice and short, and were just of homer, so nice job on that. The second page of songs and stuff is a nice addition as well.

^^Needs Improving^^
The graphics are really ugly in this. Your buttons are just rectangles with gradients, and some of the text is kind of hard to read. It would also be nice if you separated the clips by type (Greeting, etc) And also, a background would be good.