FattyWhale's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[Tetris for everyone!]

ANOTHER Tetris game?

^^Good Points^^
The music is good. Tetris Trance is a very good song and is obviously fits the game very well. The game worked fine and was face paced as well.

^^Needs Improving^^
NG doesn't need another tetris game. There are already hundreds just like this. I'm starting to think that people are just copying the code from somewhere and putting in their own crappy graphics. This is exactly like many Tetris games on this webiste and I really detest unoriginality.

Simmolissack responds:

^^good points^^
i understand your point of view and you are entitled to it.

^^needs improving^^
If you are SO sick off playin tetris games... why play mine?

[Winzows BETA]

Another windows parody....

^^Good Points^^
The only part that was good about this was the graphics, and they weren't even that great. I liked the login screen, that was kind of funny, and the recycle bin is also humorous.

^^Needs Improving^^
This Window's Sucks things are getting really old here on NG, especially when there isn't a whole lot of work put into them and they don't offer anything new as time goes on. This has a lot of problems with it. If you are trying to look at one of the three flash movies, the window that comes up isn't on top, making it hard to view the movies. The backgrounds look really stupid, try offering something different between each one other than color. The thing with mario at the end has nothing to do with Windows...

Zerobeam responds:

Thx for the feedback.

1.It was the BETA version, so il make a full one with alot more functions that im sure you'l like!

2.Il fix these nasty symbol bugs so you can't see thru!XD

3.I dunno. Nobody complained about the backs. There from NG. Maybe it's lazy, but i think very original.

4.. I don't even know why Mario is there... It was my friends (Bertn) idea.

[Hearts]

Not bad.

^^Good Points^^
This is a very well thought out and nicely layed out game. The instructions and menu are nicely drawn and the game is well animated and pretty fun to play. I liked how one had to make an account to play the game, that makes coming back to this one more enjoyable and customizable. The game itself is pretty entertaining, nice and quick. The upgrades and downgrades during the game are a nice addition as well.

^^Needs Improving^^
I can't think of anything specific...but it's not perfect!

DBarbarian responds:

Glad the account system is getting some props. That's exactly what I was going for: replayability.
Also glad that you liked the quick play. I meant for it to be a coffee break game, and am glad that it has turned out so nicely.

Thanks for the review.

[The Color Game]

Boring

^^Good Points^^
The game is kind of entertaining and is pretty challenging. I had a hard time playing this, but got the hang of it after a while.

^^Needs Improving^^
This game isn't very original and it's not really a game to put in flash, it's more of a game just to do aloud. The graphics are really bland and doesn't give this game the much-needed excitement. This could also use some sound effects and music. The main problem I had with this game though is that the colors and words are not random at all. They repeat when you start over, so eventually I just came to memorize the first few. These need to be random for the game to be any fun at all.

Aprime responds:

that nices, any way, thanks for the review, add me to favs, if u dare, u no you want to

www.aprime.tk

[PRPG]

There's nothing to do...

^^Good Points^^
The only good part of this was that the graphics were decent. The fact that you animated the mage when it moved was nice, and the layout and menu around the screen was nice.

^^Needs Improving^^
I'm pretty sure I did about as much as this game offers in about thirty seconds. I went to the town, bought a staff, slept at the inn, and then found I couldn't do much else. In fact, I could do nothing else! There is no storyline, no enemies, only two NPC's and really this is a terrible game, because there is really nothing to do.

PlatinaBlackMage responds:

theres enemys in the second area. retard

[The Simpsons Soundboard]

Not good

^^Good Points^^
The multiple characters was a good point in this movie.

^^Needs Improving^^
The first thing peculiar is that your "preloader" is merely just a movie clip with a ball moving across the screen, it actually doesn't show the progress of the movie loading. You used some good characters, but the sounds you used weren't that great. They were of varying sound quality and can't really be used for any prank calls. I also noticed that a lot of them were pretty long and contained more than one character, which isn't useful.

Frenzy responds:

Thanks for saying that the multiple characters were a good point in the movie. However...

Your Professor Frink soundbaord had some very long quotes too; don't trash on mine when yours is basically just as bad!

It's too bad that you didn't enjoy this. Oh, well.

[Thinkcomix - Bubble Love]

Meh..

^^Good Points^^
Once again, these interactive comics are a good idea, and adding a mini-game makes it more fun.

^^Needs Improving^^
I didn't really like the characters or the storyline used in this comic. Did the game ever really have an end or just whenever you hit one of those green things? What the hell were they by the way? I didn't really find this as impressive as the other one you submitted today.

Thinkcomix responds:

The "outcome" of the comics depend on the gameplay, give it a shot!

[Thinkcomix - Sir yes Sir]

Good idea!

^^Good Points^^
This is the first time I've seen an interactive comic on NG, so this is an original, fresh idea. each frame was drawn very well and the animations and mini-game were a nice touch. I couldn't really figure out the mini-game completely, but it's a good idea.

^^Needs Improving^^
This needs some sound. Voice overs, sound effects, etc. As it is now without sound, this is pretty bland.

Thinkcomix responds:

Thanks all! These comments are all great for our improvement! I'll be posting more here at newgrounds and do leave your comments at thinkcomix.com too there are currently over 140 comix! But do check back here at newgrounds too for latest posting.

[Fentruck Soundboard]

Wow, Fentruck...

^^Good Points^^
This is extremely unique. I would bet that there isn't another soundboard for this particular character anywhere on the web. I'm not sure where the heck you found all of these sound files on such an obscure character, but with all the sound files, this soundboard is pretty entertaining, and I think I could manage a prank call out of this.

^^Needs Improving^^
Some of the sound are a little bit hard to hear, but that could be just because of the accent. Try to add a few more simple responses and questions to this and you'll be in business.

wizardman responds:

Yeah, getting the sounds took a lot of work. Luckily he was in just a coupel of episodes. The lack of simple quotes is partially my fault for my inability to do an accent and partially Fentruck's fault for never doing any simple responses. Thanks for the review though. I was hoping the unique factor would make this a fun soundboard to use.

[Easter Egg Hunt]

Fun, but really slow

^^Good Points^^
The game was coded very solidly and didn't seem to have any bugs in it. I felt that the game was very fair in how close or far I had to be to catch something. The graphics were pretty nice and I liked how you changed the music and background after every level. I also liked the fact that this was divided into levels and not just constant.

^^Needs Improving^^
I found this game to be a little boring. It wasn't very hard. I played a good eight levels before I gave up out of boredom. This could stand to either get harder, faster, or have some weird items in the game that maybe make your basket smaller or larger, just stuff to give the game a little more dimension.

Wollfman responds:

I'm fairly new to this kind of scripting and am really happy to read this encouraging review. I agree, it gets slow at times. I was thinking of speeding it up, but I've got another project underway. Thankyou for your comments and constructive critism :D