FattyWhale's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Boy and his Dragon]

Old.

It doesn't really bother me that something like this gets on NG. It started off pretty good, but the screaming part was really predictable. I mean it doesn't even scare me anymore when people put this in a flash.

[1-Up Master]

Good

The graphics could have used a little work. the sprites need to be a bit larger or the screen smaller. There was just a sense of emptyness to this flash. Liked how you added the benny hill part at the end, very funny, without it this would have gotten blammed for sure. Story progressed kind of slowly, but it had a good ending. Sound effects were obviously carefully placed. This could have used some other background music just to give it a little more shape. Overall good job.

[Mario Vs. Sonic III]

...

Just what NG needs, another fake preloader movie dealy. Atleast this one wasn't quite as obvious as the others since it did have some bulk to its filesize. So the gag has been used before and has got quite old, but you actually executed it well enough to fool some people

j00bie responds:

ya

[Echo]

Nice first try

For your first animation this was a great flash. Though it was FBF, the animations were still smooth and synced fairly well with the music. Good choice of song. Liked the graphics, good drawings. Everything else is pretty good. This is very good for a first try.

[Disney...WORLD (trailer)]

Meh

Interesting idea, but the trailer could use a little more. I would have just waited and released the full thing. Graphics were good, not much sound or violence or anything else. This sounds original, I will want to see the full thing

[RuneScape Dragoons]

Not bad

I was pretty impressed that you were able to get RS sprites from the game and make an entire movie about it. The sprites were very well done, but I didn't really like the parts that you drew yourself. The music was great. The storyline was developed a little bit slowly though and the jokes weren't that great, but still nice job.

Syrsly responds:

You do know that I drew the sprites, right? I drew all those dragoon suit type things, and I edited a ton of the sprites to have some animation. Certain sprite movements are just emotes, though.

I'm guessing you're talking about that big pillar. Eh, I could do a lot better, but I wasn't focused on it. I know it looks crappy. I'll admit that. Still, if you want the most amazing graphics, you shouldn't be watching flash movies.

[The Chicken or the egg!]

Funny.

This was a pretty good idea. I would have never thought to bring up such an old question into a funny flash. The graphics were well drawn and well animated. The voice overs were pretty good. This was also pretty funny, especially the George Bush part. Good job.

[Air Guitarin']

Good.

At first I thought this was going to suck bad, but it was alright. The graphics were very well done. Very nice animation and liked how the facial expression changed throughout. The lip syncing was great. Sounds were great, I was really surprised you were able to sync the sounds that well. The end was pretty funny. Nice job.