FattyWhale's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[Halo Marines Soundboard]

Ohh, this is bad...

^^Good Points^^
I've never seen one of these done so it is an original idea. The sound quality was pretty good and you had a good amount of sounds.

^^Needs Improving^^
I think it's obvious what needs to be done. Buttons with text, or atleast groupings by character/sound type (greeting, command, etc.). Had you added this it would have been a lot better, but right now this board is useless.

[Airhockey GAME]

Not very fun

^^Good Points^^
The game worked ok...the computer AI is pretty well done, and the three difficulty levels add a lot to the game.

^^Needs Improving^^
I just didn't like this game or find it too fun. The graphics could use some improving, and the sounds were just plain annoying. The physics were a little off, you should try making the puck float a little even if no one is hitting it. I also didn't like how there was no way to guage how hard you hit the puck.

[Horoscopes]

Pointless

^^Good Points^^
I liked how the menu layout and how it scrolled and what not.

^^Needs Improvement^^
First off, horoscopes should always come with a little guideline on how to find which symbol you are. That is a minor problem, but really this thing is pointless. It provides a maximum of ten seconds of entertainment and there is no variety in the horoscopes, which is incredibly boring. It could atleast be varying. You basically put info that can be found easily in almost every newspaper into a flash.

[Bounce Bounce Revolutions]

Good start.

^^Good Points^^
I like how simplistic this game is, it is easy to get a hang of and somewhat fun to play. It is a good idea, but could use a lot of improving.

^^Needs Improving^^
The graphics could use some enhancement, right now the rocket things are very poorly drawn. There needs to be some good music and the game needs to progress faster and have some more features added to it.

NICFLIC responds:

Thanks for the review, I hope you like version 2 better.

[4-D Pong]

Decent, but overdone.

^^Good Points^^
Well, it's pretty much bugless as far as I can see. The sound effect was pretty good, nice choice. The game was also very challenging. Took a little while to get used to, but it's a little bit fun.

^^Needs Improving^^
The layout and design is too simple. You are taking an idea that has been used so many times and has been done better so many more times. Add a menu, lives, highscore, more colors, bonuses, etc. There are so many simple things you can add to make this stand out a little more.

[Border]

Good, but flawed.

^^Good Points^^
The graphics were pretty impressive for this game, I really liked the drawings and the coloring. The sound effects were also pretty good. The controls were easy to use as well.

^^Needs Improving^^
The only main problem that I have with this game is the fact that at some points it is impossible to beat the level you are on seeing how the enemies are all the way to the right and you are unable to shoot them. It is quite frustrating.

[Dubya Dress Up 2.0]

Not very entertaining.

^^Good Points^^
You definitely have some skill in drawing since most of the drawings are very well done and look like the characters/items they represent. I also liked the sound file you put in the Bush page, but the Cheney page needs something also.

^^Needs Improving^^
First off, the filesize for this is way too large considering it is only a two character dress up game, learn to compress audio. Another thing you need is more items, there were very few and most of them weren't even layered right. Also get rid of those little bubble things, they are more of an inconvenience.

[Murloc RPG]

A great way to kill a few hours.

^^Good Points^^
Well, what can I say, there is a hell of a lot that was good about this game. First off, it has to do with WoW, so this presented a great challenge in making a flash game, but you did it nearly flawlessly. The graphics were amazing. They look just like the game itself and are very defined. The controls are very easy to follow and the game has a good interface. The sound is also very good, nice music and sound effects. This game is hella fun and kept me occupied for atleast and hour, and I will definitely play it again.

^^Needs Improving^^
Well, there isn't many specific things I can say here. In fact, the only thing I didn't like about this game was the fact that when talking, after a conversation is over, pressing the space bar again should end conversation instead of restarting it. It's not a major problem, but gets a little bit annoying.

[Special Mission]

A great game, but lacks easy controls.

^^Good Points^^
Ahh, Metal Slug, a great choice to make a game for. The graphics stayed very true to the original game and were very high detail. The music and sound effects were very good also. This game is very fun and addictive, and kept me occupied longer than most flash games do.

^^Needs Improving^^
The only reason I didn't give this game a perfect 10 for a score is because of the controls. Using the arrow keys is much more convenient and takes a lot less effort to use. Using the letter keys just got me confused and made it hard for me to play. If one can get pas the controls, this game is limitless.

[Starwars Shooter]

Good graphics and sound...that's about all.

^^Good Points^^
Like my title says, the graphics and the sound are really the only good things in this game. The shading and drawings were nicely done.

^^Needs Improving^^
The fact is, this game gets old fast. As the game went on, I started to notice that enemies would pop out at the same places each time and at the same speed. This makes the game have absolutely no dimension and makes the game very boring. Next time, add levels and more randomness.