FattyWhale's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[Console Launch: 2nd Ship]

K

^^Good Points^^
The graphics were the best part. The backgrounds were simply geniously drawn. The effect from the background is one of chaos and destruction, a fun satire on the world today with the new console releases. The game is very funny.

^^Needs Improving^^
While the drawings are good, when you started using sprites or whatever for the crazy ladies and what not that just started looking crappy. I also don't like how when you throw the controller at them, you can hit them multiple times and they can still hit you until they are completely dissolved.

[Defend Your Inglor]

K

^^Good Points^^
This is a good defense game. The storyline you layed out was as unique story about inglor. I had to admire the sound effects you chose for the game, they were really crisp and well placed. The game worked very well, even the variables with the upgrades and the money system was well thought out.

^^Needs Improving^^
The game doesn't get hard until you really play it for a long time. I would have liked this better had it got harder a little earlier. The first stages were not challenging at all.

[Cosmic Fozmik]

K

^^Good Points^^
It took me a little while to realize exactly what was going on, but when I found out that the environment and enemies were synced with the music, I was pleasantly surprised. The game functioned well and there was good detection with the environment.

^^Needs Improving^^
I was kind of disappointed in the lack of rhythm needed to play this game. I guess it isn't your fault that it was placed in the rhythm games section, but this just doesn't qualify for me.

[MelonStory]

K

^^Good Points^^
Funny introduction was the best part. The music was pretty fucked up as you said. I thought the game itself was pretty funny too. Defending the castle from that odd guy with the large forehead.

^^Needs Improving^^
I was disappointed by the game. It wasn't quite as interactive as I had hoped for. The enemy didn't fight back at all and there was really no challenge in the game, besides getting to that super crazy high level 2. The music was annoying too.

[Dobble]

K

^^Good Points^^
I assume you must have been a contender in the contest, since this game was pretty well made. The music really set the mood, it sounded much like the old school games we all used to play. The graphics were very good. Great animations and great perspective. The game functioned near flawlessly.

^^Needs Improving^^
I felt that the game could have progressed a little faster. You integrated new obstacles and enemies in very slowly, and it got boring quickly. Should have been harder sooner.

[Logix]

K

^^Good Points^^
A good idea for a game, puzzle games are too few on NG, so good job on trying to get a good one on here. Could be a good game with some improvements.

^^Needs Improving^^
The game has lots of flaws in it. For one, being able to enter and exit the board without consequence makes the game very simple, also, no penalty for going over the same block more than a few times. You could add that into this and perhaps make some type of penalty for going inside and out of the board.

[Virtual Swear Bear]

K

^^Good Points^^
I got a laugh out of this. Being this is the first Swear Bear movie I've seen I was pretty surprised by the actual tone he used, which was pretty funny, and he was very blunt, which was great. This could serve some fun to send to your friends. I also think it was a good idea to put a happy face on him in the beginning.

^^Needs Improving^^
You didn't really lip sync well with this. His lips are moving clearly long after he stops talking. Also, you could have added some more sounds to this, and perhaps played them randomly. Listening to just one clip isn't much fun at all.

[F2Jam TheMusicGame - Beta]

K

^^Good Points^^
This has much improved since the first version. The graphics are much better in this version, with the animations when you hit a key, and the menu is very functional and easy to read. I'm glad you added a lot of things that I suggested, they were needed. You had more than one song, and they were pretty challenging, though I was still able to pass both of the hard charts on this. I didn't encounter any bugs this time either.

^^Needs Improving^^
I notice that the hard charts that I played didn't use the space key at all! It's there, so why not use it. Also, try to mix it up with simultaneous keys instead of having one song of just single strokes, and other with multiple key strokes. It just makes it more interesting.

XceeD responds:

Thanks for the review.
I rarely use space because I can never see a good point to use it :/. And also, it takes a lot of skills to play the game but it's really hard making the notes (at least with the system I made so far xD). Soon, it'll be better though :D!