FattyWhale's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[Bahamon Flash Tutorial]

Not that good

I didn't really like this tutorial. It could have used some background music and a menu. The information in it was pretty good, but is already in countless tutorials. The graphics weren't bad, the flash had a nice design and color scheme. However, at some point it seemed liked the next button stopped working, or it ended quite abruptly. Work on it.

[gogo Happy & Smile]

Brilliant!

This movie was simply brilliant. The character designs were very well done, it is a character I can learn to like. The controls were pretty much the only flaw, they were a little hard to get down right, and I felt that the playing screen could have been a bit wider. Other than that this flash was great. The graphics were great for a game, the weapons were good, there was a lot of challenge, and the game has a lot of depth. Great job.

[Relax: The Game]

I don't get it...

The graphics were very good in this game, but that is about it...I didn't really get the point of it. I couldn't find any strategy in it or anything. This game wasn't that fun to play at all.

[Gladiator]

Ok

This game wasn't too bad, the graphics were good and the controls were solid, and the game is pretty fun, but it seems a little buggy. Your sword doesn't always hit right and sometimes I wasn't swinging at all when I hit the A button. This game was good, but it could use a little work

[~Newgrounds~]

Good

This was a good tutorial and it had excellent graphics and sound, but honestly, it's nothing new. This information can be found in countless tutorials all over NG. The text was also very small and hard to read.

kinetic-1 responds:

I didn't find the text hard to read. If it was funny then it was probably your monitor.

[Dress - up Nano Cris]

Decent

This was an average dressup game. The graphics weren't amazing, but still pretty well done. There were quite a few outfits, and I liked how you could change the color of everything. Pretty good, but could use some different poses or something to give it a little more.

[PongyFun]

Meh

This wasn't that good. The graphics were really bad. It needs a better scoring system and was way too easy, even on the hard mode. It could use some background music to go along with it and possibly sound effects. Pretty original game though.

[MS03: Musical Skears]

Pretty good

Still this game was kind of short, but it is quite challenging to get the extra stage. Seemed like no matter how hard I tried I can't get the target score for the second level. Nice music and sound effects. Could have used a little more challenge in beating the normal levels, they were way too easy just to beat.

AcidDimensions responds:

Praise, criticism and an opening summary all exist.

Nice work.

My only criticism now is the length.

A solid review though.

5/10

Thanks.
- Bez

[MS02: The Second Coming]

Not bad

It's only four levels so its really easy to beat, and none of the levels are really that challenging. Not nearly the best skears game. It needed some more levels and some more challenge.

AcidDimensions responds:

This review could use a little bit of praise.

I like the way you've expressed a fair bit in few words.

Elaboration and maybe a little bit about your experience (obviously you didn't get the targets...) would have further improved the review.

5/10

[MS04: Encapsulated]

Challenging

Wow, this one was really hard, I had trouble getting past the fourth level, this is a great one for people looking for a challenge. Finally you added some good background music, nice choice. I liked the intro and level designs. Now I know why its called "Encapsulated". Nice job.

AcidDimensions responds:

Nice review. You get down to specifics on a great number of occassions, considering the review length.

Again your review lack any real criticisms/suggestions though.

It's useful to know you "had trouble getting past the fourth level" and that you considered the bgm a "nice choice". (Though I'd point out I composed it, so it was a creation rather than a choice.)

Also useful to know is that you "liked the intro and level designs".

But some criticism/suggestions would give me more to work on and be even more useful. Even just one.

Praise, criticise, summarise. I consider that the minimum for a decent review.

4/10

Stay funky,
- Bez