FattyWhale's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[Edward Elric soundboard]

Not bad

You picked a good character to do a soundboard for, but I don't think you really captured the same attitudes of Ed that I would have. In the only 34 sounds on this game, I wouldn't say that you captured his anger. The sounds themselves were pretty good, though one of the short retorts was low volume. Graphics were nice, good interactivity also. Overall not a bad soundboard.

[Wack-A-Goomba]

Not bad.

This is a pretty original concept for a game. The graphics were very good. I liked how the goombas faces changed when you hit them. Sounds were very well done too, nicely synced. I felt that the hitting area could have been slightly bigger because I missed quite a few that I thought i shouldn't have. The game needs more variety too. For example levels, or penalties for missing. Overall nice game though.

[City Defender]

Good game.

At first I was kind of disappointed that the game is won by clicking the meteors and not shooting them, but this proved to be pretty original and challenging. The graphics were very good, everything is nicely drawn. The game is pretty original since you didn't use missiles or anything. Sound was good, not too overpowering. Good interactivity. Overall, nice job.

[Pacman Classic V1.0]

Not that good

First off, it's Pac-Man and I hate people who are terribly unoriginal and just take an old game and put it into flash. The graphics were the best part of this game, but even they were nothing to shout about. The game was pretty devoid of music. If you're going to copy a game atleast get some good music and sound effects from it. The game play itself wasn't that great. I got stuck on a lot of walls and had a hard time getting unstuck. I also felt that Pac-Man moved much too slow. Overall this game was lack luster.

[The 16-Bit Wizard]

Good

This game really tested my SNES knowledge. I was surprised to find so many questions that I didn't know. The graphics were nice for the most part, however, some of the pictures were pretty hard to see, especially the ones where you would ask us to name the device. The music was very good, and I liked how there was multiple choices for music. I found a few errors in the quiz though. In the Demoncrest questions, fang talisman is listed twice in the answers. And also in one of the screenshot questions where the answer is Super Bomberman, it says that I am wrong and then tells me the answer is Super Bomberman even though that's what I chose. The quiz was pretty darn long...I think a little too long, and I got bored with it towards the halfway point.

MajinPiccolo responds:

Really glad you had fun playing it, it was fun to make. The Demon Crest Question has "Fang" twice on purpose, just to phase some people out. Also the Super Bomberman question is fixed. Tell your friends to take it and see if they can beat your score.

[RaidenX]

Great!

Raiden Fighters is one of my favorite arcade games! It's nice to see someone made an excellent flash rendition of it. The graphics were damn well translated into flash as was everything else. The gameplay was really fun and just like the arcade. The controls and physics were pretty good. Excellent job!

[Cupcakes of Narnia]

Not good

I didn't really like this game at all. It was way too easy, and it didn't really make sense. The graphics were poor, didn't really get the map. Sound was kind of annoying. The game went way too slow, and for god's sake there was levels? the first level was soo long. I didn't like this at all.

[DuckHunt 1945]

Awesome game!

Graphics were alright, the drawings were a little unprofessional, but overall, it didn't hurt the game. This game was a pretty original cross, and was very well executed. Sounds were a little low quality. adding the enmies was a very nice touch as was adding the wall to hide behind. This was very hard and addictive, but it was easy to get the controls and get a good hang of this game. Overall, very good job.

[Kill Linkin Park 2]

Meh

I hate linkin park just as much as anyone else, but this game wasn't very fun. It was barely even a game, you shoot a few members of the band then the kid. The graphics were alright, nothing amazing, the voice overs were hard to heard and it wasn't very fun to play or humorous.

[Alien Stab!]

One of your better games

This is definitely better than most of the games I've played from you. The graphics were pretty good for the Atari style you were going for. The sound also went well with the graphics. The game itself had good controls and good concept, but at no point does it get any difficult and there are no stages so it gets old pretty fast.