FattyWhale's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[My Anteater Son]

(title in work)

A pretty nonsensical submission here. The animations were definitely interesting. I wish you would have stuck completely to drawn characters rather than having some bitmaps in there as well. This could have used a preloader, considering the size. And also, the size could have definitely been reduced considering the length of the movie.

[Fourth Kind in 31.7 Secs]

(title in work)

I haven't seen the movie, but I can still appreciate this. I especially enjoyed the ending, with the angry guy realizing the entire movie was bullshit, and then the 2012 reference. That part made me laugh. Graphically I think this could have been a little better, some of the animations looked a bit strange. Overall, quite good though.

[Random Happy Time]

(title in work)

Well, I wouldn't exactly say that I like it. Just a bunch of random practice animations that didn't go together. Half the time it was pretty hard to tell what exactly you were trying to animate. I have nothing against random animations, but they should at least be pretty smooth and interesting, unlike this one. Also, you changed styles throughout, which was kind of odd. Some scenes were fully colored, others not. Looks like you just slapped this together.

[The Hell Are My Legs 9]

(title in work)

Another good episode. The play button was especially interesting. I had to laugh from the irony when I saw the Snakes come up. The one snake growing a pair of legs was also pretty unexpected, so that made this episode unique. Overall, a good addition to this series.

[Can i have a kleenex ?]

(title in work)

Not too bad at all. For your first animation, it's really good, since you weren't afraid to try stuff in three dimensions. This is definitely above average work for someone just learning animating. Definitely keep at it. Hope to see some expanded pieces from you in the future.

[Violinist on a Building]

(title in work)

Heh, I wish I knew the context of this audio clip you used. Care to enlighten me? I thought this movie was pretty hilarious to watch. The timing with the music was great, and I enjoyed the appearance of Duck.fla. Animations were funny. Classic stuff right here. Keep it up!

[Dr. Horrible Monologue]

(title in work)

An interesting take on the mind of a super villain. It was humorous to hear him talk about his problems, which were surprisingly just like the problems of normal people I suppose. That parallel was quite funny. At times the animation looked a bit awkward, but overall, the artwork was well done. Nice movie, good luck in your class.

Cynny responds:

Thanks, yeah overall there could be so much improvement~
but for my first ever animation, I'm pretty happy with it :)

[MrsCriblam Kills A Whale]

(title in work)

A pretty lack luster effort for the most part. There really wasn't any one part that really stood out against the others. They were all pretty poorly done. Loud noises and poor graphics were what brought this down. The only part that was mildly good was the Johnny Bravo reference. Other than that, wouldn't want to get this as a birthday gift.

KhawnerL responds:

<RobHalford> "They were all pretty poorly done"
<RobHalford> get fucked

[Flee fla Floo]

(title in work)

Hmmm, I don't really get it. The sound was definitely interesting. I think the strange sound effects made this movie what it was, though they seemed to loop over each other (kind of hard to tell). Graphically it wasn't too interesting; a bit too simple to me, with not a whole lot going on at all. Overall, too short and not much content.

[WildFire Project]

(title in work)

A neat animation. The music was good, and I think you did a good job animating to it. The animations themselves were pretty smooth, and quite interesting to watch. Didn't really seem to have much fluidity or storyline, but nonetheless, a good animation. Cuts off a bit abruptly though.