FattyWhale's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[A Collection of Guilt]

(title in work)

Definitely a mighty effort here. A very long track and sounds like a lot of time went into this. I'm not sure if it's the actual quality, or simply the fact that the NG audio portal is really shitty at loading songs, but the quality sounded a little off to me during some parts.

Goatchrist responds:

The bitrate reduction hurt a lot, I have a higher quality version on my myspace, if you want to hear it.

Yeah, it was a lot of work :)

Thanks for the review!

[Dødslegge]

(title in work)

You had a pretty good mix of drums and guitar here, and both were equally good and equally represented in this song. It sounded really cool when it was put all together. Not really a fan of the ending though, it seemed a bit abrupt as if you just decided to stop with this. Good job though.

Bonemill responds:

THanks man, the production is twenty times better than all of my old crap. The drums ended abruptly and I figured if I ended it like that people would still be headbanging after it was over like. I WANT MOAR.

[==(Goodnight)==]

(title in work)

This song was really quite nice sounding. For some reason parts of it reminded me of the game Earthbound, not sure why though. I thought the subtle percussion that you added in about half way through made this more interesting and gave it some more depth. Nice job.

[The Worlds Shortest Loop.]

(title in work)

It sounded pretty crazy. I think if you made a full length song with this kind of intensity and craziness to it, I would really like it. However, this is only a two second loop, and a bad one at that. It doesn't loop very smoothly at all, which is the point of a loop. You can clearly tell when the clip begins and ends, which defeats the purpose.

[DnA]

(title in work)

Not that I know a whole lot of DnB songs, but I thought this one wasn't too bad. It had a cool beat throughout and some unexpected tone changes throughout that were quite delightful. The only thing I'm not quite a fan of is that abusive farting noise that is very prominent in some parts of this. Just a bit annoying to me. Loved the ending to this as well.

[Shoop Da Whoop Yo]

(title in work)

Honestly I was a bit disappointed with this one. Mainly because the title included Shopp Da Woop, however, it didn't sound as shoopy or whoopy as I would have expected. In fact it just sounds like a generic techno sound. Nonetheless, a good track overall, but disappointing mostly because of the title.

[Rough mix-Doomsday zone]

(title in work)

Sounds like a great heavy metal track. Even though it is unfinished it sounds really good, man. The guitar work was freaking epic. Awesome job there, can't wait to hear the final version, though I'm not really sure this could get much better sounding!

[red lite]

(title in work)

Not too bad, but not very memorable either. It was incredibly repetitive and nothing much really changed throughout the entire song. A bit boring for my tastes. Definitely needs some more powerful and memorable parts to it that stray a bit more from the normal beat felt throughout.

snayk responds:

I guess house music isn't really your thing. Most of it is repetitive.

There are several changes in this track just to keep it fresh so it doesn't get too boring, but of course not everyone will like it. I'm extremely pleased with this song and think it's one of my best. It's definitely among the best of my dance songs.

For me, there ARE powerful and memorable moments. It depends on the person, but that's how it is with all music, and I understand that this piece just didn't do it for you. It's supposed to be a relaxed dance song; soothing and easy to listen to.

Thanks for the review.

[Mini loop 1]

(title in work)

Ok, it loops pretty much seamlessly, so I suppose you have accomplished your goal. However, I don't feel that I would ever use this in a submission, nor would I smile upon one that used it. It's really quite annoying listening to it multiple times, as its just a few claps. Gets annoying quick.

[Externia]

(title in work)

I see really no problems with this piece. It's got a very strong and prevalent base pretty much throughout and is pretty repetitive and chill, as a trance song should be. Even when you changed the tune throughout it still was a great trance tune. I'm surprised by the low score on this.